Friday, February 28, 2014

Hide and Seek (Ian Rankin) “Saturday” – Conclusion

Sure enough, many of the “side issues” come into play in the culmination of this story.  The plot is structured in a rather complex knot after all, though we couldn’t really see most of it coming.  The relationship between John’s ex-girlfriend, Gill, and her new boyfriend, Calum McCallum, the DJ comes into play as a major clue about “Mr. Hyde” comes to light from Calum through Gill.  Some space is given to John’s drive to the police station in Dumfermline, even naming the streets along the route from Marchmont  (south of Edinburgh castle) through the old town area and north to the major road connecting to the amazing bridge that crosses the Firth of Forth and connects Mid-Lothian to Fife.  A nice description of the drive, which ends with John meeting Gill, then walking up to the police station.  Then … segue to Tracy and Nell in the hospital.

This plot device prevents the reader from learning what John learns, so that the ensuing action loses all predictability; a reliable old mystery plot device used very adroitly in this case.  More photos of boxing matches come to light, like the ones found in the offal bathtub, with our heroes still apparently not aware of why they’re important.  And, yes, Tracy is finally nabbed by the bad guys and carted off, only to be discovered by John much later during the climax of the story.
Rebus rents a tux to go make his appearance at the club owned by Finlay, one of the wealthy contributors to the planned anti-drug campaign.  Not knowing what Rebus knows, we are unaware that this is where the fan gets hit until well into the action.  The disturbance caused at the door to the club’s bar is curious until we learn, much later, that it was planned by John himself to create a diversion so that he can leave unobserved to find the incriminating evidence in another part of the complex.
And now, the obligatory scene where the hero gets into a jam that it looks like there’s no way out of.  Locked into a small room with a large mirror in one wall, he realizes too late that he has been duped; followed into a trap and sealed away.  It’s actually rather far-fetched that he ends up putting his fist through the mirror – a one-way mirror – and damaging his tormentor enough to then grab him by the throat … but mystery writers can’t seem to avoid stretching our credulity at this point in the plot, in my experience, at least.  He then gets the drop on Lanyon, a further stretch of artistic license; and the wealthy man’s henchmen - sensing that their employment situation is about to deteriorate – simply run away … the most dubious stretch of all.  Mystery writers seem to get in a hurry at the end to get the climax over with, and seem to cut corners a bit regarding what is believable and what isn’t.  For me, these events could have been fleshed out quite a bit without losing the climax’s punch.  Or maybe I’m wrong about that, maybe there is a protocol to this that great writers are aware of and I’m not.  It just seems to me that the fireworks at the end of a story like this are always too brief, too hurried. 
There isn’t much of a “wrap-up” to be done at the end; once we find out what has been taking place and where and why, the questions are pretty much all answered.  We’re never told what kind of deal John had to make with McCallum for the information he got, but we can assume it resulted in a lighter sentence or something along those lines.   Certainly Gill has washed her hands of McCallum at this point. It’s a nice parting gift to the reader when Gill shows up at John’s flat:  “There was a knock at the door.  He had hope in his heart as he opened it.  Gill Templer stood there, smiling.”






Join us next time (March 7) for March’s book of the month: “Hammerfall,” by C. J. Cherryh.  (The first segment will cover Chapters 1-7.)

One of the most renowned figures in science fiction, C.J. Cherryh has been enthralling audiences for nearly thirty years with rich and complex novels. Now at the peak of her career, this three-time Hugo Award winner launches her most ambitious work in decades, Hammerfall, part of a far-ranging series, The Gene Wars, set in an entirely new universe scarred by the most vicious of future weaponry, nanotechnology. In this brilliant novel -- possibly Cherryh's masterwork -- the fate of billions has come down to a confrontation between two profoundly alien cultures on a single desert planet.

No comments:

Post a Comment