For this reader, the prose was greatly improved, or perhaps
just more fitting to the scenes throughout this entire quadrant. The battle between the Wreckers and the Regulators
was told at just the right pace and pitch as well. Owen’s escape was quite cleverly designed
into the plot, with a nice touch of inventiveness. His difficulties finding his way back to land
and to the carnival crowd were well depicted, too. Perfect pacing throughout this section, as
far as I’m concerned, though it seemed a more demanding task than those posed
by the plot line earlier in the book.
Throughout the story, the lyrics and the plot linked up very
well, with a little give and take in sequencing. Too much alignment with the sequencing might
have been awkward. The consistent
sprinkling in the text of lines from the lyrics never became boorish (though
some might not agree, I acknowledge!) and the inclusion of lines from other Rush
songs on other albums became almost amusing.
I’m pretty sure I caught them all, though my knowledge of Rush lyrics on
the whole isn’t quite as encyclopedic as some.
Owen’s reuniting with the carnival people, especially with
Francesca, was poignant enough to moisten the eyes, maybe more than a little,
and was a very fitting emotional climax to the story as a whole. The Garden, which is the last song on
the album, is one of Rush’s most beautiful songs ever. Getty Lee spoke of it in an interview I saw
online as an important departure from the band’s normal musical approach and he
seemed excited and proud of what they had done with it. The book plays it up very nicely to conclude
things.
The text even fleshes out the ideas in the song somewhat,
especially pointing out the importance of both Love and Respect, in
combination: “…everybody wants to be loved and respected. And neither is any good without the
other. Love without respect can be as
cold as pity; respect without love can be as grim as fear.” Anyone with a familiarity of Neil Peart’s
lyric-writing isn’t too surprised at something as profound as this line – and
yet I have to wonder if this one is Kevin’s?
My hat is off to both these fine gentlemen for treating us to such a
meaningful experience. Thank you, sirs!
February's book: Bloodland: A Family Story of Oil, Greed, and Murder on the Osage Reservation, by Dennis McAuliffe! First segment, Part One on Feb. 1.
February's book: Bloodland: A Family Story of Oil, Greed, and Murder on the Osage Reservation, by Dennis McAuliffe! First segment, Part One on Feb. 1.
No comments:
Post a Comment